
”Yes, we all know that”, said Mittu.
”Yes, we all know it,” said Albert. ”But I do not understand the need for the matter to create curvature in
space-time. Can’t the reverse be true where space-time curvature manifests as Matter or Energy?” Albert put
forward a tricky question for Mittu to grasp.
”I am not getting you”, complained Mittu.
”All right, I may be wrong, but have you ever noticed distorted shadows on the ground when you walk
around?” Asked Albert.
”Oh yes!” exclaimed Mittu. ”When the sun rose, I noticed my shadow on the ground growing smaller as
the sun goes up. Depending on where I stand, sometimes part of my shadow vanishes or gets modified until it
is out of certain regions. I was fascinated by those and think of it as some magic property of certain ground
regions!” explained Mittu.
”Wonderful! That’s great observation”, said Albert. ”You are right. It is the magic of the ground. That
magic is the curvature of the surface. Since Light travels in straight lines, wherever there is a curvature, the
images get distorted.”, clarified Albert. However, Mittu needed more convincing argument. So he asked: ”I am
not very convinced by what you say. My ground is flat, and there is no curvature!”
Albert raised his eyebrows and continued, ”It is not that there is no curvature. Since your brain sees
everything as flat 2D space, you cannot visualise it. You see only the projection from the 3D curvature on your
surface!”
”Oh, My! You are challenging the ontological existence of modified shadows! I am confused,” said Mittu.
”I am more concerned about the ontological existence of matter!” said Albert. ”If space-time curvature
can create the notion of matter, the world is much better!”
”Wait, wait. . . ” interrupted Mittu. ”Matter is Energy. How can curvature create it”?
”Good point”, nodded Albert. ”But how did you conclude that space-time has no inherent Energy? The
Field equation demands it”.
”But where did it come from?” questioned Mittu
”From the same source all the matter came from!” smiled Albert. ”See, I do not have an answer to your
question. It is beyond my comprehension. But if space-time curvature can bring in the notion of matter, you
don’t need a big bang or inflation to create the universe. Simple quantum fluctuations can create space-time
vibrations and result in microscopic particle creation! ”
Mittu stared at Albert and said, ”That’s a long shot! I don’t think that I can agree.”
”Yes, yes, it is”, agreed Albert. ”Let us experiment”, continued Albert while picking up Mittu and placing
him on one of the arms of a turbine in his set-up. ”Walk around’ he said. Mittu went left and right, up and
down, when Albert asked, ”Do you find anything peculiar?” ”No,” said Mittu. Albert started turning the turbine
at a constant speed. Mittu cried out, ”Oh, something is going on. I am feeling pulled down!” He said. ”Yes, you
are!” exclaimed Albert ”because you are moving in that direction!” he continued. He then stopped the turbine
and landed Mittu on the ground. ”How do you do that?” asked Mittu in excitement. Albert took Mittu on the
platform of a toy lift and switched it on to move upwards. ”Oh,” Mittu said when the ride started. When he
became silent, Albert asked, ”How do you feel now?”
”Nothing special! There was something similar to the earlier experience, but now everything is normal!”
he confirmed. Albert switched off the lift. ”Ho!” said Mittu. ”I felt something similar now, the same way I had
initially, but with a difference. It looked exactly opposite to my initial feeling,” said Mittu.
”Excellent observations Mittu and thank you for your corporation” Albert took Mittu out from the lift and
said. ”In one, you experienced a constant pull in one direction all the time while in the other, it was there
initially and finally but were opposite in nature, right?” Albert tried to clarify his experience with Mittu.
48